For some reason the response on Twittah to the JSTOR downloader guy killing himself has been a round of open access bragging. People are all proud of themselves for posting all of their accepted manuscripts in their websites, thereby achieving personal open access.
But here is my question.... How many of you are barraged by requests for reprints? That's the way open access on the personal level has always worked. I use it myself to request things I can't get to by the journal's site. The response is always prompt from the communicating author.
Seems to me that the only reason to post the manuscripts is when you are fielding an inordinate amount of reprint requests and simply cannot keep up. Say...more than one per week?
So are you? Are you getting this many requests?