Oct 18 2011 Published by drugmonkey under Scientific Publication
The notion that there is such a thing as a "dump journal" in your field should be treated like:
1) Fight Club
2) Beer goggles
6 responses so far
3) A level-5 biohazard zone
As Voltaire said, one man's dump journal is another man's reach.
May not have been Voltaire, actually.
I have reviewed for some of these alleged "dump journals." I can attest that there are some folks who lack even the ability to generate garbage worthy of the dump.
Depends on why you are dumping the paper. If its because the results are crappy, then its best to keep it secret. If its because the results are solid but mundane, well there's nothing wrong with a dump journal.
We had a name for them: "Acta Retracta," but some of those journals are perfectly good. Sometimes, you just can't get the whole perfect story together because of time, graduation, expense, etc, or it's just a good place to clear your lab notebook.
So is that a vote for "Beer Goggles", Namnezia?
Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.
DrugMonkey is an NIH-funded researcher who blogs about careerism in science. And occasionally about the science of drug use.
Site Admin | Theme by Niyaz
Drugmonkey Copyright © 2018 All Rights Reserved